Tales of Terror and Mystery
The Black Doctor
"Shehaddoneherbesttobringhimtoamorereasonableframeofmind,buthewasveryheadstrongwherehisemotionsorprejudiceswereconcerned.
Uptothispointtheyounglady’sevidencehadappearedtomakeagainsttheprisonerratherthaninhisfavour.Thequestionsofhercounsel,however,soonputaverydifferentlightuponthematter,anddisclosedanunexpectedlineofdefence.
Mr.Humphrey:Doyoubelieveyourbrothertobeguiltyofthiscrime?
TheJudge:Icannotpermitthatquestion,Mr.Humphrey.Weareheretodecideuponquestionsoffact—notofbelief.
Mr.Humphrey:DoyouknowthatyourbrotherisnotguiltyofthedeathofDoctorLana?
MissMorton:Yes.
Mr.Humphrey:Howdoyouknowit?
MissMorton:BecauseDr.Lanaisnotdead.
Therefollowedaprolongedsensationincourt,whichinterruptedtheexaminationofthewitness.
Mr.Humphrey:Andhowdoyouknow,MissMorton,thatDr.Lanaisnotdead?
MissMorton:BecauseIhavereceivedaletterfromhimsincethedateofhissupposeddeath.
Mr.Humphrey:Haveyouthisletter?
MissMorton:Yes,butIshouldprefernottoshowit.
Mr.Humphrey:Haveyoutheenvelope?
MissMorton:Yes,itishere.
Mr.Humphrey:Whatisthepost-mark?
MissMorton:Liverpool.
Mr.Humphrey:Andthedate?
MissMorton:Junethe22nd.
Mr.Humphrey:Thatbeingthedayafterhisallegeddeath.Areyoupreparedtosweartothishandwriting,MissMorton?
MissMorton:Certainly.
Mr.Humphrey:Iampreparedtocallsixotherwitnesses,mylord,totestifythatthisletterisinthewritingofDoctorLana.
TheJudge:Thenyoumustcallthemtomorrow.
Mr.